Interpretation (was Re: Dumbledore's "“peaceful expression”?

[potioncat]

No: HPFGUIDX 141806

Neri:
> Again, I don't have any problem with interpretation. I just think that
> treating interpretation as canon might lead you to some weird places.



Potioncat:
I agree the "look of peace" was an interpretation that sort of fixed 
itself as coming from canon; I also think the interpretation itself is 
still valid. I'll also accept as valid the argument the the expression 
is meaningless, although I wouldn't agree with that view.

Now, consider the famous 5 hour delay that has so tarnished Professor 
Snape's otherwise gleaming reputation. That's interpretation too.

I think many, (very, very many) of us have at one time or another, so 
convinced ourselves of some theory, we've forgotten it wasn't proven 
canon; or we were surprised when JKR took its basis in an unexpected 
direction. It's not a bad idea to go back to canon every now and then 
to make sure we've got it right.