NECESSITY of killing/ What would DD want?

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 141878

„«	SSSusan:
<SNIP>
> You do realize when you say that this "may support the
> interpretation that Flamels were going to choose their great
> adventure soon anyways and they just made their choice faster,"
that
> it CLOSELY MIRRORS the argument many DDM!Snape or Things Aren't
What
> They Appear on the Tower fans say, don't you?
>
> That is, that DD was *dying* on the Tower and knew it, that he was
> fully prepared for the next great adventure, that he wanted to die
> in such a way as to prevent Draco from murder and to get the DEs
out
> of Hogwarts, but that he needed HELP to accomplish this? 
„«	<SNIP>



Alla:

Snort, sorry, you correctly put it that this is not my position at
all.
Because even though the way you put it DOES mirror the Tower
situation in a backwards way ( IMO) - you are postulating that
Flamels are Dumbledore and Dumbledore is Snape, correct? I don't see 
how it
supports Dumbledore asking Snape to kill him and that is what I was
originally responding to.

Besides, I was probably being unclear - I was speculating that
Flanels were ready to die BEFORE stown was destroyed, since " it is
all for the best" could be read as I wanted to do it anyway. What I
am trying to say, I speculate that Flamels would have stopped
drinking the Elixir soon in any event, therefore I am NOT sure that
they needed any help, just that what happened was for the best, but
they did not ask for it.

Am I coherent or not really? I think it is time for me to go to
bed. :-)

I am also quite convinced that Dumbledore may had nothing to do with 
stone destruction in the first place, as I said upthread, then the 
analogy fails completely, IMO

>
> Siriusly Snapey Susan, who is pleased to know that neither she nor
> Alla will gloat when *whichever* one of us eats her crow.
>


Alla:

MAHAHAHA. Who knows maybe I won't resist a possibility to gloat a
little bit, tiny-tiny bit?

I hereby give you the permission to do the same if I will eat my
crow. :-)

Alla