Why it had to be Sirius

[colebiancardi]

No: HPFGUIDX 141949

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Corgi <darkcorgi at y...> wrote:
>
 > Corgi:
>  
> My personal theory concerning Sirius' death, especially after 
J.K.'s insistance that it was a necessary one, is that Sirius' 
falling through the veil is forshadowing how Harry ends up killing 
Voldemort without staining his soul with the killing curse.  Maybe 
it's farfetched, but the way J.K. brings things up it's a possiblity 
along with the 'he never died' theory a lot of the fanbase has.
>  
> Corgi
>

errrgggghhh!!  If that is how Harry defeats Voldy, I wonder if there 
is a *way* to come back from beyond the veil.  If Voldemort never 
dies, then where is he?  Would he reek havoc amongst the *others* 
that are behind the veil?  Could this led to more fan-fic after book 
7?


It is a very good theory - I don't think it is farfetched at all, 
Corgi.  Harry, I am sure, will make a visit or two to MoM in book 7.  
He might try to contact Sirius, as Luna did tell him those who have 
departed are always there - and you can hear them.

colebiancardi
(I do hope JKR does do some more writing on the Veil bit; I thought 
it would be in book 6, especially with the info that Luna gave Harry)