Is Snape good or bad?

aussiegirl711 rozcheeks at adelphia.net
Sun Oct 23 01:02:45 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 141987

Snape- when discussing this character I often get mixed views on his 
attitude. Is he good or bad? Many who believe Dumbledore (lets call 
him dd) is not dead, feel Snape is good. Others believe he is 100% 
evil. What is my opinion? Well honestly, I think Snape is neither good 
nor bad. Although he isn't the happiest person, I don't think he is a 
terrible Death Eater.I feel Snape (who *SPOILER* we learn is the HBP 
and is AMAZING at potions) was asked by dd to put the potion in place 
of the horcrux. The potion, which seemed to weaken dd, in fact made 
him able to withstand the unforgivable curse. Other Death Eaters saw 
dd die (so Snape would not be killed by the vow....he did "attempt" to 
kill dd)I have many more unanswered questions (as do we all)and am 
hopefully going to get more insight by chatting with all of you please 
put your opinion.

aussiegirl711









More information about the HPforGrownups archive