Is Dumbledore fully human?

Brenda luckdragon64 at yahoo.ca
Mon Oct 24 23:12:50 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 142056

Luckdragon:

This might be way out there, but I'm working on a theory about why 
Dumbledore's death may be different from the deaths of Sirius and 
Cedric; and why Dumbledore may possibly be resurrected or still live 
on in some form to help Harry.

In GOF chapter twenty "The First Task" Moody tells Harry "Madame 
maxime and Karkaroff will tell their champions everything they can 
to win" Moody says, "They want to beat Dumbledore. They'd like to 
prove he's only human."

Most probably this is just a figure of speech, but Jo has a way of 
throwing in the odd unobtrusive line that later becomes quite 
important. This statement, combined with all of Dumbledore's amazing 
abilities, age, aptitude for languages, championing of all races, 
mysteriousness, seemingly being all knowing, ability to become 
invisible without a cloak, being the only one who LV fears, along 
with the questionable way he died and the phoenix form arising from 
his tomb can also indicate that Dumbledore may have been part human 
combined with another intelligent, powerful life form. Of course 
these attributes can also be due to hard work and diligence, but if 
that is the case why are there not more wizards like DD? Does anyone 
else think there may be more to DD than has been revealed so far?







More information about the HPforGrownups archive