Snape-AK-dueling club

[doddiemoemoe]

No: HPFGUIDX 142143

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "agdisney" <agdisney at m...> wrote:
>
> We keep wondering about the AK at the tower.  To be more specific, 
why 
> was it so much *stronger/different* then other AK's that we've 
seen.  
*snip*

Doddiemoemoe here:

I loathe to post this theory because I really do not like Snape; 
however, I have had this thought in the back of my mind for weeks now. 
I think that while Snape may have said, "Avada Kedavra"...there may 
have been some silent/nonverbal spellwork going on...

I think Snape may have cast a spell to remove the "stopper of death" 
he gave to DD after DD's hand injury.

We know that DD was seeking Snape after drinking that awful potion.  
We've seen Snape do some healing work on Malfoy after Harry's 
sectumsempra spell...We know that DD's hand never healed, and that the 
curse never spread any further than his arm. (physically anyway)

This means that Snape may not have cast an unforgivable curse...yet it 
still leaves him casting the spell that finished DD.

I know Snape cast some spell, because it makes absolutely no sense for 
DD to take a flying leap off the tower when Hogwarts students were in 
danger.

Doddie