Has Professor Trelawney been kidnapped?

[zgirnius]

No: HPFGUIDX 142187

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "lucianam73" <lucianam73 at y...> 
wrote:
>
> I'm sorry if anyone has posted this before. 
> 
> I think Professor Trelawney might have been kidnapped under 
> Voldemort's orders during the Death Eaters invasion of Hogwarts, 
> while everybody was busy in the Astronomy Tower. 

<snip lots of nice support for juicy theory>

> While things were going on in the Astronomy Tower, better and more 
> able people (Bellatrix? Voldemort himself?) were in the North Tower 
> kidnapping Trelawney _ in my opinion.
> 
> Also in my opinion, Dumbledore's death came as an unexpected, but 
> big bonus to Voldemort _ Snape is probably in the heights of glory 
> right now.

zgirnius:
Well, if anyone posted it before, it is news to me anyway! *Cool* 
theory. I like it! Even though it has one disturbing (to me) 
implication. Only Harry and DD know the full contents of the 
prophecy, suggesting the DoM employee who filed it is dead. Who, 
other than that dead guy, Harry and DD, know *who* made the prophecy? 
Snape...

Well, OK, maybe Snape identified the Seeress who made the Prophecy to 
V all those many years ago. I feel better now.