Harry's Lack? of Skill (Was Re: Harry's character development)

[regalusblack]

No: HPFGUIDX 139395

> > Steve/bboyminn wrote:
<snip>
>>I will concede that Harry has immense talent and some skill at
>fighting. He also has fierce determination and great courage and
>daring; all excellent characteristics for an effective fighter, 
>but I still say he is hopelessly ill-prepared to face Voldemort. 
<snip>



I felt that way too while reading HBP, frustrated even, at Harry's 
disinterest in training himself. But from a writer's standpoint, my 
sense would be that it would be better for Harry to be at a gross 
disadvantage--much more interesting that way. If he'd worked hard in 
HBP to develop his skills, I think as readers we wouldn't feel as 
much suspense. Harry HAS to be an underdog here. Too, JKR has 
discussed how she's working in a genre, and battles between baddies 
and underdogs are a part of that. 

On another note, I think the series as a whole questions the idea of 
formal education--teachers are often fallible, classes & lessons 
pointless. What's more important is friendship, loyalty and courage. 
I think the last book will show Harry vs. Voldy with the odds so 
ridiculously stacked against him . . . and through the usual means--
serendipity + quick thinking + something to do with "love"--Harry 
will prevail.

Cheers,

Sheryl