Academic dishonesty

zgirnius zgirnius at yahoo.com
Sat Sep 3 21:37:27 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 139457


> Ladyhawk:
> 
> From what I remember reading in all the books is that the class 
> were a combination of theory and practical practices. In 
> Transfiguration and Charms the students were expected to do the 
> magic in class and also required to do essays on the theories behind 
> the magic.

zgirnius:
Thank you! I wish I had remembered this myself...and what are the 
written parts of the OWLs about? Probably theory as well.

I think the reason we do not see more emphasis on this in the books is 
that 1) it would be boring for us Muggles, mush more so than reading 
about mishaps in transforming teacups into tortoises, or whatever, and 
2) it is not an enthusiasm of Harry's. Had the books been written from 
Hermione's POV the curriculum might seem to have a lot more emphasis on 
theory...






More information about the HPforGrownups archive