Recursion: See Recursion

finwitch finwitch at yahoo.com
Mon Sep 5 11:35:30 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 139576

Gatta:
> Here's a poser for you: In the Muggleverse that runs alongside the 
> Wizarding World in the Harry Potter books, do J.K. Rowling and the 
> Harry Potter books exist? And if so:
> 
> (1) Does the existence of the books in the (fictional?) Muggleverse 
> generate another level of WW and MV, in which the books exist and 
> generate...and so ad infinitum? (Inspired by staring fixedly at the 
> Land of Lakes butter package while the coffee water heated.)

Finwitch:

Nah - it'd be - as they ARE published later than Harry's adventures --
maybe, like the Quibbler, a form to publish things about Harry? Say 
Harry met J.K. Rowling on a train and told her the whole story. 

> (2) How does the Wizarding World feel about being "outed" in so 
> cavalier a fashion? Do they figure the Muggles think it's just 
fiction 
> and this too shall pass, or is there a delegation from the MoM on 
its 
> way to rearrange Ms. Rowling's memory?

Finwitch:

Well, they'd probably figure that Muggles will think it's fiction. Or 
maybe they did wipe her, which explains her writer's block, but Harry 
paid her a second visit... how would we know?
 
> (3) For that matter, is there a WW that runs along side *this* 
> Muggleverse? And how does *it* feel about being "outed" in so 
cavalier 
> a fashion...
 
Finwitch:

Well, if what I speculated above goes on, well... Besides, maybe it 
*would* be time for wizards to reunite Muggle Society. The Ministry 
wouldn't like it, of course - as the Ministry *exists* to hide 
Wizardkind from Muggles...

Finwitch






More information about the HPforGrownups archive