[HPforGrownups] Re: Keep Harry Horcrux Free Challenge!

[K G]

No: HPFGUIDX 140156





Yes, the other huge problem with this comes from the mouth of the 
author herself;

`...I had said that explicitly the killing curse rebounded on 
Voldemort...'
Edinburgh "cub reporter" press conference, ITV, 16 July 2005 

Which does suggest that Voldemort really was trying to use Harry's 
death for his final Horcrux. 

Also, DD's suggestion that Voldemort used Nagini as his final 
Horcrux, would;
1. explain his snake-like features. 
2. suggest that Voldemort failed in generating his final Horcrux at 
GH 

Brothergib



Okay,

Let's assume that Harry was not going to be a horcrux and that he was just going to be a tool to make one.  What was going to be the horcrux?  My sons and I tend to believe it had to be something, maybe the sword or maybe something as yet unknown, from Griffindor.  Godric's Hollow... Godric Griffindor.  Somehow it all fits.  So what was used?  Was it left behind?  Where did the sword come from?  Was it always at Hogwarts?  

My theory is that TMR found it in the Chamber of Secrets and was somehow unable to get it out when he left.  He came back for it.  He was unable to get the teaching position.  Did he get someone else to get it out for him?  Somehow he got it and kept it for just the right murder.  What better than to use the item from SS's "enemy" in the defeat of his "enemy" in order to make his final horcrux?  The sword got left behind when LV turned into vapor!Mort and either Hagrid, Snape, or DD found it in the rubble and took it back to Hogwarts.  This is gives DD the first real clues about what is going on.

I am quite sure someone has come up with this already but with me working 11-12 hours per day, I have not been able to keep up with all of the posts!!

moonmyyst



Summerland Hills Shelties

home of their royal highnesses: 
Southcrest Faerie Song "Belle", (bi-black), AKC
Southcrest Sugar Quill "Honey", (sable/white), AKC 
Chocolate Sundae Hugs "Hugs", (sable/white), AKC, CGC, IHDA Herding level 1, RA
Little Valentine Kisses "Kisses", (sable/white), AKC, CGC
Summerland's Blueberry Muffin  "Blue", (tri-blue merle), AKC, IHDA Herding level 1
Cerridwyn Summerland Reveille "Revie", (sable/white), AKC

and in memory of:  
Southcrest Phantom Spirit  "Ghostie", (bi-black), AKC, 9 time conformation class 1st.
		
---------------------------------
Yahoo! for Good
 Click here to donate to the Hurricane Katrina relief effort. 

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]