Keep Harry Horcrux Free Challenge!

[Mil]

No: HPFGUIDX 140166

K G (moonmyyst) wrote:
> > My sons and I tend to believe it had to be something, maybe the
> > sword or maybe something as yet unknown, from Griffindor.  
> > Godric's Hollow... Godric Griffindor.  Somehow it all fits.  So 
> > what was used?  Was it left behind?  Where did the sword come 
> > from?  Was it always at Hogwarts?  


Caius Marcius wrote:
> But the sword was used to destroy the diary - so the theory of 
> Horcrux!GG-Sword that gives us the same problem as Horcrux!Harry, > unless we want to postulate a sort of civil war between the 
> various fragments of Voldemort's soul. 


Mil:

Actually, no... the sword was used to kill the Basilisk; the 
Basilisk's FANG was used to destroy the diary... there's the 
difference... 


Caius Marcius:
> Also, it seems unlikely that Dumbledore, who spent his final year
> in high-Horcrux-Hunting mode, would have failed to notice this.  
> DD says to Harry in chap. 23 "I am confident, however, that the 
> only known relic of Gryffindor remains safe." So I'm sure that DD
> ran the sword through his Horcrux-scanner, or whatever magical 
> means are used to detect their presence. 

 
MIL:

But you must remember that Gryffindor's sword didn't become Horcrux!Sword because LV failed to complete the murder; he was Vapormort before he could make his final horcrux...  

I really like this idea... JMO, of course

Back to lurkdome...
MIL