Voldie's Wand and other details
darqali
darqali at yahoo.com
Fri Sep 16 15:55:37 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 140289
Asked before, and got no answer, so trying again:
*How did LV regain his wand?*
When the events at Godric's Hollow were over, Harry's parents were
dead and Voldemort had become Vapormort.
We just had comment about doing magic with a wand; Dumbledore's
powers being perhaps diminished due to a damaged wand hand; a wizard
doing magic holding a wand with his toes if he had no hand ..... but
we know the Vapormort stage of LV's career left him unable to use a
wand .... {He said so himself while recounting his history.}
*Where was Voldermort's wand in his years of exile? How did he later
recover it?*
The question is followed by the most obvious speculation:
Peter Pettigrew was the one who betrayed the Potter's location to
LV. So possibly, even *probably*, Pettigrew was present at Godric's
Hollow. He could have retrieved LV's wand {and the intended Horcrux
object as well} after the house "blew up" and LV lost his body. {Or,
some other Death Eater present could have done so ... as we have no
specific knowledge as to who might have been present .... but clearly
it had to have been someone in LV's camp; and someone who knew that
LV was not dead, finished, too; best alternative to Pettigrew would
be Barty Crouch Jr., because other candidates, such as Malfoy Sr were
ready to write LV off.}
But then Pettigrew fakes his own death {strange parallel} by
"blowing up" a street full of Muggles, leaving behind his severed
finger to indicate he was killed, thus ensuring no one will seek him
in hiding and framing the one person who could have fingered
{*snicker*} him {Peter} as the traitor ..... his act sends Sirius
Black to Azkban, where no one will listen to the truth, that Peter
was the real Secret Keeper, and the traitor, not Sirius.
*So how did Peter Pettigrew manage to keep possession of his own
wand, much less hang on to the wand of LV for his master?*
As for the time of Hagrid's arrival at the Dursely's:
Dumbledore had to learn of the events at Godric's Hollow, and decide
what to do; then Hagrid had to be summoned by Dumbledore and
assigned his task; Hagrid had to go to Sirius Black to borrow his
motorcycle {was that at Grimould Place, London? Or some other
residence of Sirius'? Where?}; then go to Godric's Hollow {on the
borrowed bike}; then search through the rubble of the ruined house
and extricate Harry {no problem, says Hargid, but how long did it
take?}; and only *then* could he begin his journey to the Dursely's.
Seems to require more than 4 or 5 hours to me ....
There are a lot more troubling "out of time" issues in Potterverse
than this to me .... for one simple example, the Chamber Of Secrets
was supposedly made, and hidden, in the era of the founding of
Hogwarts ... about 1,000 years ago from present day. So how could
the hidden passage to the chamber be in a modern-day girls' bathroom
through the plumbing of a sink? Were wizards using modern bathrooms
1000 years ago?
Now *theres* an issue of time-out-of-place to chew over.
darqali
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive