Snape ,Dumbledore and Neville

[kmohdia]

No: HPFGUIDX 140395

 

Basically I believe:

1.Snape isn't a death-eater .He was working on Dumbledore's orders .
2.Dumbledore isn't dead .He made a horcrux.

The supportive evidence being: 

1.Dumbledore uptill now had deliberately not given the post of DADA 
to Snape .Why ? We finally get the answer in book 6 p.418 (end of 
chap. "Lord Voldemort's Request "):
" Oh he definately wanted the (DADA) job,"said Dumbledore....You see 
we have never been able to keep a DADA teacher for longer than a 
year .."
             I think that finally Snape got his coveted wish only 
because Dumbledore needed to  use him to get closer to Voldemort and 
establish his trust by acting as a decoy himself.

        Snape is Dumbledore's man through and through .Why else 
would he have saved him ? In chap " horcruxes" Dumbledore says" Had 
it not been.... for my own ..skill,and for Professor Snape's timely 
action...I might not have lived to tell the tale."
Even if didn't kill Dumbledore to save him for Malfoy to do it 
because of his " Unbreakable vow ". Why did  he spare Harry's life , 
especially now that  he was leaving Hogwart's for good there was no 
need to cover up his identity  of  "spy" for Voldemort.

That brings me to my next theory that Dumbledore has indeed created 
a horcrux for himself .As for the idea that he cannot kill – he has 
killed .Its obvious :p.470 (chap "horcruxes ") he says :"You are 
indeed forgetting ...you have destroyed one of them (horcruxes).And 
I have destroyed another ".So,as he has killed it's almost imposible 
to believe that Dumbledore would  die so easily before he had 
despensed with Voldermort.

The death was too easy ...which supports the fact that it was part 
of Dumbledore's plan . Recall how he said to Harry ( p.468 )  " the 
careless way in which Voldemort regarded this Horcrux seemed most 
ominous to me.  It suggested that he must have made ..more 
Horcruxes ."  
Well only if he had a horcrux  , would Dumbledore so easily let 
himself die .No matter, if for him
 " death is but the next adventure for him ".. but I think he 
wouldn't leave Harry alone ( or the Wizarding world ) to deal with 
Voldemort esp NOW .

What do you think ?
( Mohammedi aka violet )

P.S.
I am just wondering what on earth happened to Neville ?
He  seemed to  have  disappeared . Any ideas