Hogwarts functioning during missing 24 hours

M.Clifford Aisbelmon at hotmail.com
Tue Sep 20 08:02:15 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 140509

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, fuzzlebub85 at a... wrote:
> Elyse:
> I dont know if we can be sure that Mcgonagall was at  Hogwarts.
> I presume Hogwarts was closed at the time of Harry's attack.
> I  mean, Harry's birthday is always during the summer holidays,
> at which time  Hogwarts is closed for the vacation.
> So if Harry was attacked on his first  birthday, Hogwarts must have 
> been closed, and the teachers were on  vacation.
> (snips the rest)
>  
> Kaylee: Sorry to disagree, Elyse. Harry was attacked on Halloween. I  
> remember this clearly, but feel rather foolish for not having PS/SS  
> on hand. *glances around* Anyone have the relevant canon?

Valky:
I think it's in another book not PS/SS, maybe POA. 
In any case I agree, I do recall that canon places Harrys age at 15
months, which would be approximately the end of October.

OTOH I think Hogwarts *was* closed/ish. The whole WW was celebrating
the downfall of Voldemort, I don't think Hogwarts would have excepted
itself from a WW party. Perhaps children were allowed to use the floo
to go home and whoop it up with their parents. At least, I don't think
there was formal classes on that particular day in WW history. :D










More information about the HPforGrownups archive