Hagrid in GH

Hagrid aussie_lol at yahoo.com.au
Tue Sep 20 13:43:38 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 140521

"musicgal3001" wrote: <snip>
> Actually, one thing is bugging me. How did Hagrid get to GH before 
> Sirius? He can't apparate or anything...
> 
> Musicgal.

-aussie / norbertsmummy-
With an ID like "norbertsmummy" for a guy, you can guess I put a bit 
of thought into Hagrid.

Hagrid was limited in Magical ability since he never got past 3rd 
year of school. And apart from being an OOTP and trusted by DD, I 
don't think most OOTP members viewed him as more than an oddity to 
put up with.

I am pretty sure that none of the Marauders were overly friendly 
with Hagrid, so I doubt he'd been to Godric's Hollow before.

What evidence athat the Marauders and Hagrid weren't close? 

Mainly because of the Marauders map itself. 

HBP doesn not show the Room of Requirements on the Map - because the 
Marauders never got into that room to plot it.

In POA, Peter / Scabbers knew he could hide in Hagrid's hut because 
it was not on the map - the Marauders had not plotted it ... maybe 
because they had never been inside. Scabbers went inside with Ron, 
and so knew he was safe there, and knew he was invisible to the map 
while at Hagrid's.

So this adds more quiries about how Hagrid could find GH before 
Sirius got there.
aussie/norbetsmummy






More information about the HPforGrownups archive