Is Harry an idiot because he thinks Snape is guilty? Was: Why wizards are so i

[pippin_999]

No: HPFGUIDX 140566

Alla: 
> I am not saying of course that  there are no possible different 
> interpretations of what happened on the Tower, but are you saying 
> that they should have more sense to Harry that what he just saw?
> 
> He has  the most important piece of evidence - Dumbledore is dead, 
> Snape  threw Avada at him.
> 
> I guess my question would be  why  this makes Harry an idiot?
> 
> What is more reasonable than Seeing Dumbledore's body?

Pippin:
How do you think Harry is going to feel if he manages to get
Snape killed or punished, (or thinks he has) and then finds out that 
events on the tower were not what they seemed to be.  Do you think 
he's *not*  going to ask himself why he didn't notice the conflicting 
evidence before? Do you think he'd be proud of himself if he
realized he had let his hatred run away with him?

If he's going to be an Auror, I certainly hope he is not going to
make a habit of disregarding evidence just because it doesn't fit 
with his theory of the crime!  


Pippin