Lily so wonderfull?

[lyraofjordan]

No: HPFGUIDX 140615

Torinarg wrote: 
> One point I have is the view that Lily Evans/Potter was a most 
> extraordinary witch, perhaps the most extraordinary, however in POA 
> Lupin tells Hermione that she is the most extraordinary witch of 
> her age he has ever met, and he knew Lily very well.
> Any thoughts?


Lyra: We do have some canon that Lily was an accomplished witch... 
>From PS/SS (chapter 4) Hagrid says "Yer mum and dad were as good a 
witch and wizard as I ever knew. Head boy and girl at Hogwarts."

And of course, from HBP, we have Slughorn's assurance she was a natural at potions. 

Other than that, we really don't know much about her skills at all, 
certainly not enough to do a side-by-side Lily vs. Hermione comparison.