Snape's future (Was: Snape's other books)
Hagrid
aussie_lol at yahoo.com.au
Fri Sep 23 14:12:50 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 140661
--- "cubfanbudwoman" <susiequsie23...> wrote:
> SSSusan wrote previously:
> > >OTOH, I still can't quite imagine Snape abandoning Draco. He
might
> > >not keep him with him long while he's on the run "I could see
him
> > >arranging for his safe deposit *somewhere* -- but I can't
imagine
> > >his lugging Draco along with him. The only way I think Snape
would
> > >stay with Draco long is if they both end up hiding at the
Malfoys'.
>
>
> Saraquel:
> > I've been rereading `Flight of the Prince" and there is no
evidence
> > given about whether Snape actually disapparated with Draco or
not.
> <snip canon>
> > It could be that as soon as the 3 DEs and Draco got beyond the
> > boundaries they disapparated without waiting for Snape so
there
> > is a possibility that Snape and Draco have already been
separated.
> >
> > Whatever happened at that point, and even if Snape is ESE or has
> > decided to still continue as a spy (both of which I doubt) I
can't
> > see them hiding at the Malfoy's.
>
>
> SSSusan: <snip>
> > What I found interesting was my reaction to your comment that
Snape &
> Draco might already have separated, since there's no actual
evidence
> that they disapparated together. I found myself thinking, "Well,
> that might have happened *if* Draco knew and trusted those other
> three DEs and elected to go with them, but that's the *only* way
it
> would have happened."
>
> Now, why was my reaction that strong, I wonder? ... NO MATTER
WHICH side
> I imagine Snape to ultimately be on, I still can't imagine him
> abandoning Draco at that moment. Partly it's the Unbreakable Vow
and
> the promise he made to Narcissa to watch out for Draco. Partly
it's
> that I think he has watched Draco all 6 years he's been at
Hogwarts.
> But I think, truthfully, it's also partly that, for all his
> horribleness, I think Snape typically DOES try to protect his
> students.
>
> Wow. Noble!Snape? Am I deluding myself?
-aussie-
Snape delayed his return to LV for 2 hours with an excuse. There
would be no excuse this time. Both Draco and Snape would want to
report on DD's death and claim credit for their part in it.
I just wonder if LV had alternative reasons for getting Draco to AK
(tear his soul) other than just get DD out of the picture. If U-No-
Poo had another purpose, the report may make him angry.
-aussie-
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive