Straightforward readings?.

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 140728

potioncat" <willsonkmom at m...> wrote:
 
> The biggest eye-opener for me is the 
> incredible damage Harry does to
> Draco. I cannot get around the horrible
> injury he inflicted. I keep forgetting
> that Snape was able to cure Draco to 
> the point that he could walk out. But
> more amazing is that the punishment was
> merely several Saturdays of detention. 

I don't think Harry should have been punished at all, he was just
defending himself from an unprovoked attack from somebody about to use
an Unforgivable curse. He would have been justified in killing him to
prevent that. 

  Eggplant