[HPforGrownups] Re: 7 parts of V's Souls/ 7Books

[Phil Vlasak]

No: HPFGUIDX 140758

crypticamoeba wrote:
> > What if being the maniacal type of genius she is, JKR decided way
> > back to infuse her books throughout with this idea of 7 being a
> > magical number (canon: HBP).  Given that there are 7 divided parts
> > to voldemorts soul (canon: HBP).  What if she decided to introduce
> > us to one part per book.  They may be small and unobtrusive but
> > there.
> >
> > Book 1:
> > Book 2: Voldemort's Diary (Destroyed)
> > Book 3:
> > Book 4: Naghini (sp?)
> > Book 5: Locket in #12 (theory based on canon locket in OotP and RAB
> > being Rudolfus A Black OotP and HBP)
> > Book 6: Marvolo's Ring
> > Book 7:
>
> Valky:
> I agree. And, note also, that The Diary, Nagini and the Locket, are
> all partially revealed for the first time *prior* to Harry's return to
> Hogwarts
>
> The Diary - In Flourish and Blotts Book2
> Nagini - Little Hangleton Book4
> The Locket - Grimmauld Place Book5
> The Ring - On Dumbledore's Hand Book6
>
> This would place a partial reveal of the Book1 Horcrux, in Diagon
> Alley. IMO this one really could be already found by clever listees
> here, in Ollivanders shop. I am pretty sold on that myself.
> and the Book3 Horcrux too should be revealed in some part of the Leaky
> Cauldron, Florean Fortescues, or the Magical Menagerie or even in the
> Daily Prophet or on the Knight bus!! phew LOL good luck hunting
> through that lot for it. <g> I think that this one is supposed to be
> very well hidden.
>
>
> > Crypticamoeba:
> > concerning Hufflepuff's Cup we came up with the House Cup and
> > Quidditch Cup both as possibilities i do not think either are truly
> > possible.  As V intended the Diary to reside at Hogwart's (prob. the
> > Chamber) and 2 Horcri in the same location seems unsafe and
> > Harry/Dumbledore would have recognized it.
> >
>
> Valky:
> Lets not write off the trophy cabinet quite yet, I think it might
> still come into play. Here are some more observations in agreement
> with the pattern that you're talking about.
>
> The pattern continues into second time in each book that we seem to be
> getting a sniff of the hidden Horcrux. It usually happens around the
> midwinter of the books.. Observe:
>
> The Diary - Harry gets a hold of it shortly after Christmas/COS
> Nagini - There is a reference made to Voldies Snake around
> Christmastime again, can't look it up sorry, Don't have book so I am
> recalling from memory, correct me if I am wrong.
> The Locket - We see Kreachers Lair with shiny objects retrieved from
> the Drawing room in it, again at Christmas time.
> The Ring - The pattern deviates here, but I suspect that this is in
> keeping with the pattern. The next time we see the ring is just prior
> to October, and Dumbledore says, the Ring is no longer a Horcrux.
>
> The second half of the pattern seems to work for known Horcruxes, but
> what about our speculative ones?
>
> Ollivanders and wands are not mentioned around Christmas time in PS/SS
> as far as I can find, but I am still looking.
>
> In POA Harry's midwinter is spent learning the Patronus, and obsessing
> over his Firebolt and the Quidditch cup, there's hints about the Time
> Turner and Lupins Werewolf affliction, some Fire Salamanders and
> Divination Lessons too.. The best match I can find with the beginning
> of the book is the Divination lessons - Harry reads the covers of some
> interesting books on Divination in Diagon Alley.
>
> OTOH things do look good for the Quidditch Cup which is mentioned in
> both sections of the book, although that's hardly unusual, its still a
> match.
>
> Valky

Now Phil:
A better match for the pattern in PS/S
would be the  large black and silver screaming volume that Harry opened at
Christmas in the Restricted Section in the library
the books contained powerful Dark Magic never taught at Hogwarts, and only
read by older students studying advanced Defense Against the Dark Arts.
The hint att the beginning may be in Diagon
Alley's Flourish and Blotts where Harry saw
books as large as paving stones bound in leather.
Phil who is now looking through book 3.