Mcgonagal's approach to Harry in HBP

musicgal3001 leora at nycap.rr.com
Thu Sep 29 20:06:49 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 140923

Derek:
  I really hope we see a similar 
> Mcgonagal in the final book.

I honestly believe that we will have to see a similar McGonagall in 
Harry Potter and the great conclusion. I mean, Harry will most likely 
take over the Order of the Phoenix-or if not, will be a very 
important player in the Order. People realize that Harry will be the 
one to face off Voldemort, even if no one heard the prophecy. I 
believe that McGonnagall realizes that if she attempts to keep Harry 
in school, or even to treat Harry as less than a VIP in the coming 
battle, she will lose all contact with him. And that's the last thing 
the light needs to do at this point. They need to band together, and 
McGonagall is smart enough to realize that means cooperating with 
Harry and treating him as he is: a dedicated soldier.
Another thing is that I think he will need to cooperate with her, 
too. Harry will have to let other people help him with this final 
battle if he has any chance of winning it. Especially if a Horcrux is 
in Hogwarts, which it very well could be.
I believe that this idea of cooperation includes other things except 
for Hogwarts. I think Harry will have to cooperate with the Ministry 
in order to get over necessary steps.
That's my two cents


Musicgal.







More information about the HPforGrownups archive