Voldemort to Vapormort - How Did They Know?
gelite67
gelite67 at yahoo.com
Sun Apr 2 19:50:05 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 150407
I've always believed that someone else was present at GH on the night
of Voldemort's downfall. Otherwise, how would anyone besides Harry
(who couldn't remember) have known, prior to any admission by
Voldemort, that Voldemort's powers had been broken or that Voldemort
tried to perform the AK spell on Harry that rebounded on him? It seems
to me that anyone happening upon the scene afterward would think the
perpetrator simply caused all the damage and then left. Why would
anyone assume it was an AK spell gone awry if, to the best of wizard
knowledge at that time, there was no way to block an AK spell and make
it go awry?
For that matter, how did DD know in SS that Voldemort was the one who ,
in fact, killed James and Lily and tried to kill Harry? Obviously,
this is confirmed later, but how did DD know at the time unless there
was a witness who told him? (Snape, IMO) It's hard for me to belive
that Voldemort would have gone there alone -- he would have wanted at
least one DE there to impress, wouldn't he? Bragging rights and all
that.
I know that magic leaves traces, but enough to figure out what spells
were cast, which were unsuccessful, and what the consequence of any
failed spells were?
I guess I've always assumed that DD never saw Harry until Hagrid
brought him to the Dursleys. Is is possible that DD saw Harry before
then and extracted Harry's memories of the events?
Is there any other explanation for how DD knew what happened that night
other than hearing/seeing the story from a witness?
Angie
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive