[HPforGrownups] Re: R.A.B

[puduhepa98 at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 150531

Second try :>)
 
Jazmyn wrote:

I have a different theory.  Regalus drank the  same potion that 
Dumbledore later drank to get to the real horcrux and died  from it 
and people simply assumed that Voldemort killed  him.  <snip>.

>Steven1965aaa writes:

>I  don't think Regalus drank the potion.  DD made 2 seemingly  
>contradictory statements to Harry re: the cave: (1) Well done Harry,  
>one could not have done it alone, and (2) only 1 adult wizard could  
>have gone in the boat.  (I'm paraphrasing).  If we assume that  RAB 
>is Regalus, and if we further assume that Regalus used the boat as  
opposed to some other means, someone else must have gone with him.   
That other person could not have been an adult wizard, so who was  
it?  My vote is for Kreacher. <snip>
 
Nikkalmati:
There are a lot of problems associated with RAB entering the cave and  
replacing the locket with a dummy.  I suggested upthread that  he/she  switched the 
locket before it was placed in the cave by LV and LV didn't know  it.  If it 
is Regalus, of course, the locket would have to be placed in the  cave during 
WWI, not any earlier. Regalus could have been killed by the locket  or by LV 
for other reasons.  If LV found out the locket was missing, and  RAB is Regalus, 
LV would have found it in the Black house.
Any  thoughts?
Nikkalmati




[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]