Danger at the Wedding?
kiricat4001
zarleycat at sbcglobal.net
Fri Apr 7 14:25:13 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 150659
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "klmf1" <KLMF at ...> wrote:
>
> Forgive me if this has come up already, but is anyone else out there
> wondering if the Bill and Fleur wedding isn't going to be a scene of
> destruction? With Arthur working for the Ministry, Bill as a Curse
Breaker, the
> Weasleys as "blood traitors", and poor Molly's bad dreams ---not to
mention
> the foreshadowing of the whole family pointing at "mortal peril" on
her clock,
> a wedding with all those people together in one place seems a great
> opportunity to knock off a few pesky muggle-lovers and HP & Co
Marianne:
I've always felt that, since there are a whole slew of Weasleys, some
of them would have to be bumped off before the end of the series. Not
that I dislike any of the Weasleys, but, if we are to feel the true
horror of what the DEs mean to wizard society, we're going to have to
have a bunch of deaths of characters we know fairly well. Knocking
off one biggie per book (Sirius in OoP and DD in HBP) isn't enough.
And JKR did say she had to be "ruthless" in writing these books,
didn't she?
In HBP there are IIRC several instances where we are told via one of
the Trio or through the Daily Prophet that some relative of a Hogwarts
students is killed. It serves to remind us that the DEs are back in
business, but doesn't really hit us with an emotional impact the way
the death of say, George, would, because we don't see the impact on
the main characters. I'd include the death of Emmeline Vance and the
disappearance of Florean Fortescue in this category. When we hear of
their fate we sit up and take notice, but, IMO, we are not hit with
the same sort of shock and sorrow we'd be if it was a Weasley.
One other thought - several listies including me expressed
dissatisfaction with HBP in that there was no memorial, or mention of
one, for Sirius. Other people responded with how this was completely
logical because such a gathering would be a danger to the Order as
they would be convenient targets for an attack by the DEs. I would
suggest the same conditions exist for a Weasley wedding. However, now
that 12GP is securely in Harry's possession, perhaps the wedding could
be safely held in there, with Mrs. Black providing genteel commentary
in the background...
Marianne, who's not really bloodthirsty but who expects several
emotional wallops in Book 7
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive