Slytherin redemption
horridporrid03
horridporrid03 at yahoo.com
Mon Apr 10 21:43:32 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 150802
> >> Joe Goodwin:
> > <snip>
> > To me this means that one of the lesser known Slytherins, say
> > Goyle or even Parkinson is going to step and and decided that it
> > is their best interest to work against Voldemort.
> > <snip>
> >>Lupinlore:
> <snip>
> So I guess I'm saying I agree with you, and I think it may well
> happen (and the hints about the deleted scene with Theodore Nott
> from earlier books seem to lean in that direction), but it seems
> like an eleventh hour development if there ever was one. I wonder
> if this was the role the Weasley cousin was originally supposed to
> play?
Betsy Hp:
I agree with your reservations, Lupinlore (which I snipped), that
it's awfully late in the day for unknown, or barely known,
Slytherins to come forth and help rejoin their house to the Hogwarts
whole. (I've discounted Theo Nott since the deleted scenes bit on
JKR's website. I think Nott's story has gone the way of Dean's.)
> >>Joe Goodwin:
> > It just seems to me and Snape and Draco both working for the
> > good guys after having seen the error of their ways is a good
> > bit too contrived for a writer as imaginative as JKR.
> > <snip>
> >>Lupinlore:
> I agree. We also should remember that Peter Pettigrew is lurking
> out there as a possible figure of redemption.
> <snip>
Betsy Hp:
But, Peter Pettigrew is a Gryffindor. What could he possibly do to
help the Slytherin end of a Hogwarts uniting party?
Frankly, I've been waiting for Draco to join Harry's gang since book
one. It's a classic bit for the school-days genre, IIRC, for former
peer enemies to become friends. (Just as classic as the new
understanding and respect for the curmudgeonly teacher. <g>)
But beyond that, Draco *is* the face of Slytherin for Harry (and
therefore, the readers). We're talking about the healing of a rift
centuries old. There has to be a profound coming together to
overcome something that embedded into the school consciousness.
Something beyond a few "rebel" or "minor" Slytherins.
That Draco comes from two major Slytherin families is important, I
think. Just as Harry befriended the major Gryffindor family (the
Weasleys), I feel like Draco's role as the Slytherin heir, in spirit
if not reality, will be important.
Betsy Hp
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive