Singing in Whoville/Slytherin redemption

katssirius katbofaye at aol.com
Mon Apr 10 19:13:25 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 150817

Multiple redemptions seems too cumbersome with only one book left.  The 
remaining Slytherins have very little in the way of character 
development and I believe only Pansy has ever had more than one line.  
Pettigrew could pay his debt without redemption.  I seem him finally 
fed up with the scorn he receives from Voldy et al.  He will strike 
back with a big screw you curse that saves Harry but is done only out 
of anger and bitterness.  As others have mentioned I think Malfoy just 
made his final exit from the books.  JKR finishes people off.  Lupin 
and Sirius and all the DADA teachers are excellent examples.  Moody 
just barely hangs on.  Too many people need to see the light to begin 
to save minor characters and I do not think it is JKR's intention to 
create an evil free world.  Umbridge is her example.  Saving them all 
could only happy on Cindy lou who's watch.

katssirius









More information about the HPforGrownups archive