[HPforGrownups] LV: Where'd He Go and How did Frank Know "Something"
puduhepa98 at aol.com
puduhepa98 at aol.com
Tue Apr 11 02:36:01 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 150826
Rebecca wrote: re:the Longbottoms
> but not to kill Neville. They specifically were the ones the DE's wanted.
> (Another question: who the hell *sent them* if LV was MIA? Don't blame me
> for asking, blame Rowling for her site's answer to the question of the
> choice.)
> Wouldn't that line of thought perhaps lead one to the speculation Frank
saw
> what happened at GH? JKR's also mentioned before that we maybe haven't
see
> the last of the time turners -could it be that Ministry would have allowed
a
> time turner's use to find out just what happened to the most notorious
> terrorist in years? In PoA, time isn't to be meddled with and bad things
>Ffred:
>_Someone_ had to pass on the message that LV was gone, and that someone had
>to be a reliable enough witness to be believed by the Ministry and the
>media. Word was out very early the following morning for Vernon to see the
>wizards out on the streets on his way to work.
<snip>
>The Longbottoms are a reasonable surmise to have gone with him. ,snip> If
they
>were then on the front page of the Prophet as eye-witnesses, then that's
>enough to make them marked men for the surviving DEs.
Nikkalmati:
Good thought here. I, however, had thought that whoever sent the DE's found
out right away LV had disappeared after going to GH. James and Lily were
dead, so he had been there and they clearly didn't kill him. What was the next
stop on his list? I don't think LV would take any chances with making a
mistake when killing the "one born in July". I think he planned to go directly
to the Longbottoms after taking care of Harry and get Neville (a la Herod
killing all the baby boys in Bethlehem to get Jesus). Therefore, they went to
the Longbottoms figuring that LV had gone there and the Longbottoms could tell
them what happened.
That still leaves the question who sent Bella and Company?
Nikkalmati
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive