Myrtle: Blood Status, and the Basilisk attacks of 1943
dracojadon at yahoo.co.uk
dracojadon at yahoo.co.uk
Tue Apr 11 17:45:12 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 150854
Was Moaning Myrtle a muggle-born? (Bear with me.) Draco calls her a
mudblood (CoS chpt.12), but what does he know? He's already admitted
to 'Crabbe' and 'Goyle' that his father won't tell him anything, and
'mudblood' isn't exactly a precise designation.
The question is: was Myrtle singled out for attack, or was she just
in a bad place at the wrong time? Red Hen makes a point of saying
that of course Tom would have wanted to kill her - anyone would
(http://www.redhen-publications.com/Hagrid.html), but that contains a
bit too much speculation for me. It depends on how many girls
bathrooms Hogwarts has for people to go and cry in.
What form did the other basilisk attacks take in 1943?
Petrifications? Is this how Dumbledore can so confidently say
(paraphrased) that 'It means, Minerva, that the Chamber of Secrets is
indeed open once more'?
"dracojadon"
*wondering what will be the fate of HPfGU after book seven*
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive