Judas Gospel role for Good Snape?

talamariam talamariam at yahoo.com
Wed Apr 12 14:42:28 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 150890

I read the news about Judas Gospel - the gnostic view that Judas 
betrayed Jesus under instruction from Jesus himself -- and see this as
support for JKR's role for Good Snape.

I finished reading HBP with a conviction of Bad Snape -- but later I
believe that it will be better plot for Book 7 if Snape is actually
good.  The supports for both theories are slightly more to Good Snape
in my opinion, barring the thinking that killing somebody (DD!)can be
an excusable deed.

Then came the Judas Gospel news.

Tal









More information about the HPforGrownups archive