Subject: Trevor is a Horcrux (Was The Sting: Lucius sent Bella)

[career advisor]

No: HPFGUIDX 151050



> Carol:
> How could the Longbottoms' knowledge of or guessing the
> existence of a Horcrux become when they're both insane, and how would
> it further the plot?

>Neri:
>Gee, there are so many great possibilities here. Say, the Horcrux is
>somewhere in plain sight in the Longbottoms' house. Or Neville
>inherited it from his parents and always had it in his possession. Or
>when he's 17 he'll inherit it. Or Frank and Alice will somehow manage
>to convey to him where it's hidden. And Bella might come after it
>again, probably with several DEs in tow. And just think what the shock
>of seeing her might do to Frank and Alice. We may have the attack on
>the Longbottoms all over again, only this time playing live, and with
>Neville a wizard of age. Now *this* would be what I call BANGy.

DA Jones 

Well, yeah Bellatrix will battle Neville. But also at the end of the long Lucius  lla string is the old  Trevor is a horcrux theory!  Let's say that at the last moment  one of the Longbottoms managed to transfigure the Horcrux into  Trevor. Trevor escaped or the toddler Neville somehow rescued him. Isn't Trevor somewhat old for a toad (or is he a frog?). And it would explain why Trevor/Voldermort is always trying to escape from Neville. I say Trevor is the Cup Horcrux. 

No, I don't believe this theory but it is humorous; makes use of an overly weird hanging plot point  and does seem to be JKR's style, sort of. Also remember it  is also the sort of thing kids would like, and these are chidlren's books right?  :)

Another minor point. It seems to me a lot of peole say Alice is an Auror. Frank is an auror obviously, but isthere canon for Alice?  I don't recall.  

What do you think?