Harry Potter: A Horcrux

[latha279]

No: HPFGUIDX 151053


> On 4/17/06, Leonard Kim <muhahawa at ...> wrote:
> > Rather than argue whether this theory is or is not likely (I 
happen
> > to think it is) I was wondering whether anybody in the past 
several
> > thousand posts or so has tried to work out its consequences if 
true?
> >
> > Assuming all other Horcruxes are disposed of ...
> > the most basic outcome, which has been proposed here before is 
that
> > if Harry is a horcrux, then he has to die in book 7...
> 
Peggy worte:

> Not necessarily.  Now, I don't believe that Harry is a Horcrux, but 
if
> he were, I can imagine a scenario where Harry and Voldemort switch
> bodies (that is, Harry possesses Voldemort's body and vice versa).  
If
> this happened, it's possible that Voldemort and his soul piece could
> become one inside Harry's body, and--presto chango!--no more Harry
> Horcrux.  Now that's a bit of magic.
> --
> Peggy Wilkins
> enlil65 at ...
>

My question is : why didn't that happen in the MoM Battle at the end 
of OotP? It should have happened then. I feel, the thing that Harry 
has so much of that the Dark Lord knows not of it INTUITION more than 
Love. It was intuition that told him what to do with the dairy in 
CoS. It was again intuition that made him hold on to his wand and 
will the beads to go towards LV. 

So, if LV were to possess Harry and the pieces of souls were to merge 
again, why didn't it happen when there was an opportunity before? 

Point also is, if there is a piece of Harry in LV, why did he also 
suffer mortal agony? He should have felt more comfortable there. 

Can't say - is my vote on this matter. (And I am still a Harry-is-NOT-
a-horcrux believer). I don't think JKR would make it that gross even 
for the drama and hype it could create.

Just my opinion,
Brady.