legalities, dark magic, and dark wizards

stevemac yahoo at stevenmcintosh.com
Wed Apr 19 20:05:25 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 151153

stevemac:

 From reading some of the recent posts about DD and Parseltongue, I  
thought it was interesting that I did not have a clear distinction  
between these categories...

Although it is easy to get the general 'dark magic = bad'  
connotations, I'm really curious about what others have to say on  
where the definitions and dividing lines are. They seem very gray,  
and by some definitions I have read, HP has definitely used full- 
blown Dark Arts/Magic in the final scene with Snape in HBP - he knew  
that the purpose of the sectumsempra was to cause harm, and used it.

I'm just wondering where the boundries lie between illegal magic,  
dark magic, and dark wizard.

stevemac







More information about the HPforGrownups archive