legalities, dark magic, and dark wizards

Najwa ryelle80 at yahoo.com
Thu Apr 20 02:55:54 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 151184

> 
> Tonks:
> In the books there are 3 unforgivable curses, as you know. These are 
> unforgivable because they 1. Takes away another person right to 
> choice or free will.  2. Causes pain for the pleasure of causing 
> pain or to gain something for oneself as a result. 3. Deprives the 
> other person of the right to live a full natural life.  The 
> underlying precept behind all of these is a lack of respect for the 
> other and selfishness on ones own part. 
 
 
Najwa:
I have had a question about one particular spell or charm I suppose.
The love charm. it's not unforgivable, yet it takes away a person's
right to choice and free will of love, doesn't it? It's almost like a
love based Imperius. I can understand if it was a spell to increase
love that was already there or perhaps keep it going, but to make
someone fall in love with you? It almost sounds like ruphynol mixed in
with a bit of the cayote ugly scenerio, only long term.









More information about the HPforGrownups archive