Prefect Ron? There's worse.
Joe Goodwin
joegoodwin1067 at yahoo.com
Thu Apr 20 18:35:59 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 151223
Magpie:
Draco seems easily as logically picked as Ron--he's a more obvious
choice, actually, imo. He is a leader in Slytherin house.
Joe:
Is he a leader in Slytherin? Aside from Crabbe, Goyle and Parkinson
do we ever see other housemates following his lead? I can only think
of two times, the "Potter stinks" badges and the "Weasley is our
King" episode.
Magpie:
He's a perfectly competent student as far as I can see. <snip>
Harry would let us know if Draco was struggling academically, and
he never does. <snip>
As I said with Ron, I think the idea is more taking people who have
certain qualifications and trying to channel them in a productive
way. Nor is it a disaster in Slytherin. Draco is awful under
Umbridge in the IS, which is a completely different system, but
despite all of Hermione's warnings we don't see him abusing his
powers when he's just a Prefect. Hermione herself can also benefit
from being Prefect--she's not so adept at the job she's ready to
teach others yet as others have suggested, imo. She just has her
own set of issues and is quick to criticize what other Prefects are
doing.
Joe:
I think this hits the nail on the head. Malfoy is a fine Slytherin
Prefect just as Ron is a fine Gryffindor Prefect. They both do a
great job upholding the traits their individual House's value.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive