[HPforGrownups] Re: SHIP Ron/ Hermione /Golpalott's Third Law

[silmariel]

No: HPFGUIDX 151422


Neuman:
> > Alright then, I'll bite. What does Golpalott's Third
> > Law mean?
> >
> > "The antidote for a blended poison will be equal to
> > more than the sum
> > of the antidotes for each of the separate
> > components."
> >
> > How would one antidote be more than another? Did
> > Golpalott also invent
> > some kind of rating system?
>

Len:
> It means that you need to find the antidotes for each
> of the ingredients, then find the additional
> antidote-ingrediant that will synergize these
> individual antidotes to counteract the synergy of the
> poison's ingredients.

Oh, I thought it meant that once stablished the nature and quantity of the 
antidotes as if counteracting separated poisons, you had to add a little more 
to each of them, so that the final quantity of the blended potion is equal or 
more than the expected for the sum of the simple antidotes.

Joe:
>Hermione is smarter than both Harry and Ron but it isn't by as great a 
>measure as by the level her academic ambitions/insecurities excede theirs.

Have to agree. I think Hermione is supossed to be gifted, but she has to study 
too much and put too much work into her studies to achieve her academic 
levels. I can't see her as truly gifted. It should be easier for her, after 
all, she is not in a gifted children school competing with her peers, to be 
over the top, she shouldn't have to work so hard. Just IMO.

Silmariel