Locket Horcrux
kmalone1127
kmalone1127 at yahoo.com
Tue Apr 25 03:17:26 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 151423
I've just had a thought and I apologize if anyone has mentioned this
before.
It seemes to me that there is a simple way of deducing whether or
not the locket in 12 Grimmauld Place really is a horcrux. Now, to
cover myself I want to state that I may be quite as wrong as Humphrey
Belcher, but I think it has merit.
We know that JKR has direct input into the important bits of the
movies, ie: the GH scene. If the locket is indeed a horcrux then it
is a very important plot device that pertains to the major story line.
Given that, if in the upcomming OotP movie, they show the locket or
reference it in some way, then I think we have our answer. No
director in their right mind would leave out an important clue to the
story. It would be hokey to have Harry in the seventh movie suddenly
find a horcrux when there was no forshadowing of it before. Harry
mentioning something that was not shown that has a large impact on the
story would kill the suspense, like in books when the hero suddenly
discovers a way to kill the Big Bad and it seems to have come from
nowhere, that kind of thing.
Anyway, just thought I'd put my two cents out there, let me know
what you think. (the OotP movie comes out before book seven, right?)
kmalone1127
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive