Advice, and the guilt of taking it [Was: Is Harry a Murderer...]

[sugaranddixie1]

No: HPFGUIDX 151443

> Eggplant:
> I hate Snape with a passion but paradoxical as it sounds I must
> confess to rather liking The Prince. Perhaps the young Snape was not
> quite as evil as the older version. You say some of the advice The
> Prince gave was bad, but I can't think of any. Sectumsempra could be
> useful against enemies just as The Prince said it was. Incidentally
> Harry used that spell again after the time with Draco, he used it
> against the Inferne in the cave. <snip>


ET again:
(I liked the young Prince better too, btw....)

I think Harry made a very poor judgement call in using that spell 
without knowing what it did, but I can understand why he did it. 

IMO, he made a poor judgement call again in using it against the 
Inferne because a corpse isn't going to bleed to death. ;)
He didn't know what would stop them though, so I guess it was as good 
as anything....wonder what would have happened if he'd used 
Lockhart's bone "repair" spell? :D

ET: who has been told she has a very strange sense of humor & 
considers it a high compliment. :)