[HPforGrownups] Re: Is Harry a Murderer / Killer!! ?? !! Yeah or Nah??<sn...

[Karen]

No: HPFGUIDX 151464


On Apr 25, 2006, at 9:19 PM, puduhepa98 at aol.com wrote:

> Nikkalmati:
> Yes, Harry is behaving like a teenager, but he is supposed to show  
> us a
> better way, victory through "love" or "compassion" or some such  
> positive  emotion.
> He is not there yet.
> If Harry had behaved in a less juvenile way, Draco would have had the
> opportunity to rethink his plan.  Just imagine if Harry had said  
> "Yes,  Professor
> Snape, I found that spell in a book and I didn't know what it   
> did.  I'll be
> glad to show it to you. "  Can't Harry be honest for  once?  What  
> if he went to
> the infirmary and told Draco " I didn't really  intend to kill you,  
> it was a
> mistake" ?

kchuplis:

Well, I don't know about you, but I am surrounded by people everyday  
who can't say "I was wrong" or "I don't know". I've decided where I  
work to just take the blame for everyone. I always tell them, "That's  
OK, it's my fault" when it is totally one of the other workers  
because, well, *someone* should say it. Usually, no one argues. We  
all generally know whose fault something really is.  But can they  
admit it or say anything? Nope. And that is over teeny tiny things.  
Seriously. Things that don't even matter!

Harry is just normal. I think if it had been anyone but Snape, he  
might just have said that.

I don't think he would ever go visit Draco though. I wouldn't either.  
I must be evil :D  I guess Draco did go visit Ron that one time. I  
think it was basically to gloat, and apparently try to find something  
on him (which he did by finding Charlie's letter). I'm thinkin' he  
wasn't practicing his candy striper skills. C'mon. It wouldn't happen  
in the real world, let alone in Harry's world.