Something Suspicious about Severus

[Bex]

No: HPFGUIDX 151490

> Brady:
> 
> But Sridhar, coming to the Snape point again - we all have deduced 
> enough of the canon to understand that Snape agreed to become a spy 
> long before Lily was murdered by LV. So I donot think the repentence 
> was because of that.
> 
> On the same note, this is a general question. If *WE* are able to put 
> two and two together and come to conclusion that Snape was already a 
> spy for DD before GH happened, how come people in the Order (Remus 
> and Minerva) agree to Harry's account in the hospital wing that DD 
> trusted him because Snape repented being the cause for James' and 
> Lily's deaths? Are they acting or not-in-the-know or plain dumb as 
> far as mathematics is concerned?


Did they /know/ that Snape was the one who heard the prophecy? Perhaps
the shock of the news made them forget their numbers. Also, it is most
likely that Dumbledore was the only one in the order who trusted Snape
fully - perhaps Remus and McGonagall were close seconds, but after the
shock of what happened, everyone is questioning his loyalty. Give them
time, surely one of them will start working it out.

~Yb