[HPforGrownups] Relationships; House Elves

[puduhepa98 at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 151577

Nikkalmati:
>> Here is something that has been puzzling me.   How can Kreacher 
be dangerous? <snip>  How can Kreacher betray  Sirius, the heir of 
the house of Black, even by trickery or deception? Even  with the 
collusion of Narcissa?  <snip> Kreacher's treachery does  not seem 
to fit what we have seen of house elves. <<  

BAW:
>>Kreacher betrayed Sirius to a close blood-relative;  Harry is not 
bloodkin to the Malfoys (or only very distantly).  That  makes a 
difference.


Nikkalmati:
Kreacher betrayed Sirius, the last of the Blacks, not  Harry.




[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]