Snape-Our Side

[Lisa]

No: HPFGUIDX 151675

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "deepthi_b1" <deepthi_b1 at ...> 
wrote:
>

> Coming to the other theories....has anyone shed light on the 
following passage from the 6th book, The Cave, Page 534? "Hating 
himself,repulsed by what he was doing"were the words used by J.K to 
describe Harry's actions while forcingly giving Dumbledore the cup 
filled with the potion on his orders. In fact J.K again 
uses "revulsion and hatred etched..." to describe Snape's expression 
while he was "killing" Dumbledore. Perhaps he was being forced by 
Dumbledore to "kill" him. 

SassyMomOfThree responds:

I've been a proponent of this theory since Day One!  I caught 
the "hatred and revulsion" comparison right away, and definitely 
think that it was purposely there to hint to us that Snape was doing 
Dumbledore's bidding, much as Harry was.
>
 
"deepthi_b1" <deepthi_b1 at ...> wrote:
 
> There are many more theories to this, but I just want to know how 
many more people find this theory fitting as I sure do.
> 
>
SassyMomOfThree responds:

Count me in!

~~Lisa