[HPforGrownups] Scene with likeable James WAS: Re: Eileen Pince LONGish

[sherry gomes]

No: HPFGUIDX 156314

>Irene:
> Was vicious with Molly when
>> she disagreed with him.



Sherry now:

Who was vicious in that scene?  I'd have to say it was Molly who 
was vicious, not Sirius.  Talk about hitting below the  belt!  
,the first dinner at Grimauld Place is the first time I felt very 
angry and disappointed in Molly.  She was downright brutal, when 
she had no right or cause to be.  She may have loved Harry as a 
son, but Sirius is his legal guardian, according to his parents 
wishes, no matter what twists DD took upon himself on Harry's 
behalf.  Sirius had every right to react as he did to Molly.  In 
fact, I thought he acted with amazing restraint.  i would not 
have reacted as well, I am quite sure, and I am known as someone 
who never loses her temper at other people.

Sherry