Reading by JK Rowling at Radio City - Spoilers Within (SHIP)

bridge13219 bridge13219 at yahoo.com
Thu Aug 3 14:29:43 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 156459

Random:
> "The question of H/G" is not the issue. The idea, as held by many H/G
> or R/H shippers (including JKR) that H/H is ridiculous or that anyone
> believing anything but H/G and R/H is stupid, is the problem.
>
> The idea doesn't have any merit, just because it's not the same as
how
> one person wants it to be? That would be seen as _incredibly_
arrogant
> coming from anyone else, and I'm not convinced JKR shouldn't be held
> to the same standard

bridge13219:
I've never gotten the idea that JKR thinks H/H shippers are ridiculous
or stupid (and of course we are free to believe what we like until we
have Book 7 in our hot little hands), but as this is her creation, she
is entitled to a little incredulity when she has stated specifically
and unambiguously that the ship is R/H.  I don't feel it's arrogance
on her part to "want" a situation to be a certain way.  Like I said,
it's her creation, it's her call.











More information about the HPforGrownups archive