[HPforGrownups] Re: This shall be Salman Rushdies words (Spoiler????)!?

[Joe Goodwin]

No: HPFGUIDX 156500


colebiancardi <muellem at bc.edu> wrote:

>> oh SO KEWL!!! I think JKR was doing her "normal" twisting, but the
opinion (theory) is Snape is good. And she verifies it. She discards
the DD is not dead, but stating that she has to be more explicit and
spell it out (that was his proposal, not opinion) <<

Joe:

  I still think the only way we are going to know is when the book comes out.

  When I read what you posted it seemed to me at least that she was confirming Dumbledore being dead despite his not liking it. It didn't read to me like she was confirming anything about Snape.

  Lets be honest here, what reason would JKR have to reveal anything about Snape being good or bad? It is one of the most compelling and mysterious plotlines in the books.

  I just don't buy she would give it away right before the end.

  Joe