This shall be Salman Rushdies words (Spoiler????)!?

[talamariam]

No: HPFGUIDX 156557

> > Neri:
> > <snip> So the only question is, does Rushdie's opinion also
> > imply that if Dumbledore *isn't* alive, then Snape must be
> > bad? <snip>
>
> Pippin:
> But there's another implication, which is that planning an elaborate
> ruse in order to save Dumbledore and plant Snape in deep cover is
> indeed something that Dumbledore and Snape would do, just as we
> DDM!Snapers have contended all along. <snip>


I am really glad to read these question from Rushdie (Wow! Salman as a
potterhead! Not just Irving and King! How's that?).

The question, and JKR's assertion of DD's death is really a bomb!
I tend to agree to the opinion that these pair of remarks do not
necessarily mean that Snape is bad.

But it means DD is definitely dead! Wow! How 'clarifying'!

tal!