Contradictions/ The Smiths must still have the Hufflepuff Cup

[zanooda2]

No: HPFGUIDX 156591

> Potioncat:

><SNIP>

>What's up with portraits? DD talks about Dippet and Riddle.
>The portrait never comments. Does anyone know if Dippet's portrait
>has ever spoken in any of the books?

>>Mike:

>>The only time I recall Dippet speaking was as one of the Phineas
>>chastisers in OotP after Harry sees Aurthurs attack, p.473 US.


zanooda:

I don't have the books with me now, but I also remember that it was
Dippet who said "Really!" when Harry started throwing DD's instruments
at the end of OotP. I cannot check if I'm right, but if I am, it
should be in "The Lost Prophecy" chapter.


> Abergoat:

>And it seems Tom was visiting Hepizbah on his own, not at the
>suggestion of Burkes and Borgin as I originally thought.


zanooda:

Just out of curiosity, how did you come to this conclusion? LV said
that he was sent to negotiate about some goblin armor, if I recall
right. Do you think he lied?