The Smiths must still have the Hufflepuff Cup

[seekingsophrosune]

No: HPFGUIDX 156597

> Tonks:
> At Lumos John Granger gave the prediction that the Hufflepuff Cup 
> was disguised as the House Cup. His reasoning was that the House > 
> cup brings division to Hogwarts. This is worth thinking about.

I posted my Hufflepuff Cup Transfigured in the Trophy Room theory on 
John Granger's HogPro forums on July 13.  At the time, I hadn't 
decided if it was the House Cup or the Medal for Magical Merit. John 
suggested I post it on other forums since HogPro is very small, and 
he's mentioning me as the source of the theory in his upcoming book. 
Before putting my theory on Live Journal, I reworked it since I've 
decided the cup Horcrux is probably the Medal for Magical Merit (not 
the Award for Special Services to the School) rather than the House 
Cup.  It's long, but I would love for you to read it and give me your 
opinion.

http://felicitys-mind.livejournal.com/1383.html


I also believe I found a breadcrumb trail of clues showing that the 
Fortescues are Ravenclaw's descendants, and I believe Florean's 
disappearance is Horcrux-related.  My best guess is that the object 
in question is the goblin-made tiara, and I have several possible 
theories on this post:

http://felicitys-mind.livejournal.com/2342.html

I would love the feedback of anyone here willing to take a look (skim 
if not read).

Thanks,

Felicity (aka Maureen)