Which Dumbledore ?

[spookedook]

No: HPFGUIDX 156918

Raymond:

Which Dumbledore died at top of the tower? Everyone thinks Aberforth
is the barman at the Hogs Head. What if Albus and Aberforth are twins?
JKR says look at Dumbledore`s family and says Dumbledore is dead but
does not use a forname so using this thought which died?

Tinktonks:

Very good point. How many people are known just by their surname? All
the teachers insist that Sir/Madam/Proffessor is used except for
Dumbledore and Hagrid. As grawp would not share Hagrid's surname being
a maternal half sibling than the one remaining is Dumbledore. Does JKR
EVER say that Albus Dumbledore is DEAD?

Tinktonks.