Harry as a horcrux

robertpatrickallen robertpatrickallen at yahoo.com
Tue Aug 15 15:15:26 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 156970

I originally thought that Harry was a Horcrux when I read HBP. Then I
went back and reread GOF and realized that it wasn't possible. The
reason Voldemort fell was because his spell rebounded off of Harry and
hit him. The spell he cast that rebounded was Avada Kadavera. Otherwise
nothing would have happened to him.

If Voldemort cast a spell to make Harry a Horcrux then he simply would
have bounced his own soul off of Harry and back into himself. What
caused him to fall was that he was hit with his own killing curse...but
we now know that since he had horcruzes he couldn't fully die. Not to
mention that Voldemort tries to kill Harry in GOF, which if for some
reason Harry was a Horcrux, would be very foolish.

Right now Harry can't fight Voldi because their wands share the same
core. That is why Voldi kidnapped Olivander so he could force him to
make a new wand so that Voldemort could finish Harry himself.

Robert








More information about the HPforGrownups archive